MPE Home Metamath Proof Explorer < Previous   Next >
Nearby theorems
Mirrors  >  Home  >  MPE Home  >  Th. List  >  tz9.1 Structured version   Unicode version

Theorem tz9.1 8170
Description: Every set has a transitive closure (the smallest transitive extension). Theorem 9.1 of [TakeutiZaring] p. 73. See trcl 8169 for an explicit expression for the transitive closure. Apparently open problems are whether this theorem can be proved without the Axiom of Infinity; if not, then whether it implies Infinity; and if not, what is the "property" that Infinity has that the other axioms don't have that is weaker than Infinity itself?

(Added 22-Mar-2011) The following article seems to answer the first question, that it can't be proved without Infinity, in the affirmative: Mancini, Antonella and Zambella, Domenico (2001). "A note on recursive models of set theories." Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic, 42(2):109-115. (Thanks to Scott Fenton.) (Contributed by NM, 15-Sep-2003.)

Hypothesis
Ref Expression
tz9.1.1  |-  A  e. 
_V
Assertion
Ref Expression
tz9.1  |-  E. x
( A  C_  x  /\  Tr  x  /\  A. y ( ( A 
C_  y  /\  Tr  y )  ->  x  C_  y ) )
Distinct variable group:    x, A, y

Proof of Theorem tz9.1
Dummy variables  z  w are mutually distinct and distinct from all other variables.
StepHypRef Expression
1 tz9.1.1 . . 3  |-  A  e. 
_V
2 eqid 2467 . . 3  |-  ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om )  =  ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om )
3 eqid 2467 . . 3  |-  U_ z  e.  om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z )  =  U_ z  e. 
om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z )
41, 2, 3trcl 8169 . 2  |-  ( A 
C_  U_ z  e.  om  ( ( rec (
( w  e.  _V  |->  ( w  u.  U. w
) ) ,  A
)  |`  om ) `  z )  /\  Tr  U_ z  e.  om  (
( rec ( ( w  e.  _V  |->  ( w  u.  U. w
) ) ,  A
)  |`  om ) `  z )  /\  A. y ( ( A 
C_  y  /\  Tr  y )  ->  U_ z  e.  om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z ) 
C_  y ) )
5 omex 8070 . . . 4  |-  om  e.  _V
6 fvex 5881 . . . 4  |-  ( ( rec ( ( w  e.  _V  |->  ( w  u.  U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z
)  e.  _V
75, 6iunex 6774 . . 3  |-  U_ z  e.  om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z )  e.  _V
8 sseq2 3531 . . . 4  |-  ( x  =  U_ z  e. 
om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z )  ->  ( A  C_  x 
<->  A  C_  U_ z  e. 
om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z ) ) )
9 treq 4551 . . . 4  |-  ( x  =  U_ z  e. 
om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z )  ->  ( Tr  x  <->  Tr 
U_ z  e.  om  ( ( rec (
( w  e.  _V  |->  ( w  u.  U. w
) ) ,  A
)  |`  om ) `  z ) ) )
10 sseq1 3530 . . . . . 6  |-  ( x  =  U_ z  e. 
om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z )  ->  ( x  C_  y 
<-> 
U_ z  e.  om  ( ( rec (
( w  e.  _V  |->  ( w  u.  U. w
) ) ,  A
)  |`  om ) `  z )  C_  y
) )
1110imbi2d 316 . . . . 5  |-  ( x  =  U_ z  e. 
om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z )  ->  ( ( ( A  C_  y  /\  Tr  y )  ->  x  C_  y )  <->  ( ( A  C_  y  /\  Tr  y )  ->  U_ z  e.  om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z ) 
C_  y ) ) )
1211albidv 1689 . . . 4  |-  ( x  =  U_ z  e. 
om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z )  ->  ( A. y
( ( A  C_  y  /\  Tr  y )  ->  x  C_  y
)  <->  A. y ( ( A  C_  y  /\  Tr  y )  ->  U_ z  e.  om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z ) 
C_  y ) ) )
138, 9, 123anbi123d 1299 . . 3  |-  ( x  =  U_ z  e. 
om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z )  ->  ( ( A 
C_  x  /\  Tr  x  /\  A. y ( ( A  C_  y  /\  Tr  y )  ->  x  C_  y ) )  <-> 
( A  C_  U_ z  e.  om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z )  /\  Tr  U_ z  e.  om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z )  /\  A. y ( ( A  C_  y  /\  Tr  y )  ->  U_ z  e.  om  ( ( rec (
( w  e.  _V  |->  ( w  u.  U. w
) ) ,  A
)  |`  om ) `  z )  C_  y
) ) ) )
147, 13spcev 3210 . 2  |-  ( ( A  C_  U_ z  e. 
om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z )  /\  Tr  U_ z  e.  om  ( ( rec ( ( w  e. 
_V  |->  ( w  u. 
U. w ) ) ,  A )  |`  om ) `  z )  /\  A. y ( ( A  C_  y  /\  Tr  y )  ->  U_ z  e.  om  ( ( rec (
( w  e.  _V  |->  ( w  u.  U. w
) ) ,  A
)  |`  om ) `  z )  C_  y
) )  ->  E. x
( A  C_  x  /\  Tr  x  /\  A. y ( ( A 
C_  y  /\  Tr  y )  ->  x  C_  y ) ) )
154, 14ax-mp 5 1  |-  E. x
( A  C_  x  /\  Tr  x  /\  A. y ( ( A 
C_  y  /\  Tr  y )  ->  x  C_  y ) )
Colors of variables: wff setvar class
Syntax hints:    -> wi 4    /\ wa 369    /\ w3a 973   A.wal 1377    = wceq 1379   E.wex 1596    e. wcel 1767   _Vcvv 3118    u. cun 3479    C_ wss 3481   U.cuni 4250   U_ciun 4330    |-> cmpt 4510   Tr wtr 4545    |` cres 5006   ` cfv 5593   omcom 6694   reccrdg 7085
This theorem was proved from axioms:  ax-mp 5  ax-1 6  ax-2 7  ax-3 8  ax-gen 1601  ax-4 1612  ax-5 1680  ax-6 1719  ax-7 1739  ax-8 1769  ax-9 1771  ax-10 1786  ax-11 1791  ax-12 1803  ax-13 1968  ax-ext 2445  ax-rep 4563  ax-sep 4573  ax-nul 4581  ax-pow 4630  ax-pr 4691  ax-un 6586  ax-inf2 8068
This theorem depends on definitions:  df-bi 185  df-or 370  df-an 371  df-3or 974  df-3an 975  df-tru 1382  df-ex 1597  df-nf 1600  df-sb 1712  df-eu 2279  df-mo 2280  df-clab 2453  df-cleq 2459  df-clel 2462  df-nfc 2617  df-ne 2664  df-ral 2822  df-rex 2823  df-reu 2824  df-rab 2826  df-v 3120  df-sbc 3337  df-csb 3441  df-dif 3484  df-un 3486  df-in 3488  df-ss 3495  df-pss 3497  df-nul 3791  df-if 3945  df-pw 4017  df-sn 4033  df-pr 4035  df-tp 4037  df-op 4039  df-uni 4251  df-iun 4332  df-br 4453  df-opab 4511  df-mpt 4512  df-tr 4546  df-eprel 4796  df-id 4800  df-po 4805  df-so 4806  df-fr 4843  df-we 4845  df-ord 4886  df-on 4887  df-lim 4888  df-suc 4889  df-xp 5010  df-rel 5011  df-cnv 5012  df-co 5013  df-dm 5014  df-rn 5015  df-res 5016  df-ima 5017  df-iota 5556  df-fun 5595  df-fn 5596  df-f 5597  df-f1 5598  df-fo 5599  df-f1o 5600  df-fv 5601  df-om 6695  df-recs 7052  df-rdg 7086
This theorem is referenced by:  epfrs  8172
  Copyright terms: Public domain W3C validator